← Back to overview

06. The Fatalists

Back to the contents

Previous: The Poor Man

Next: The Surprise

Johann Heinrich Jung-Stilling, Scenes from the Spirit World, Volume 1

Adin, Hasmon and Abiel, in the realm of shadows

Hasmon. Someone is walking there in the dim night! I must go to him and speak my mind. Perhaps it will ease this deep melancholy. Greetings, stranger! If you are a being of my own kind, share your grief with me. I am sorrowful beyond words in this lonely, dark region. I had to leave the world with all its joys and everyone I loved, and here I find myself stripped of anything that could give me a drop of comfort or a glimmer of joy. Whoever you may be, speak to me!

Adin. I am in just such a plight. It eases my misery to find someone with whom I can return in thought to the scenes of the past. That is the only thing left to me, the pitiful remnant of all the joys I once enjoyed.

Hasmon. What a plight we are in! So we live on after death. It is true, then, that the soul is immortal. But what an immortality! I cannot understand how the author of our existence can create rational beings who are bound to be unhappy.[1]

Adin. I was just thinking about that before you came. What is worse, we enjoy countless pleasures in the first life so that in the second we may feel their loss, and the loss of everything, all the more keenly. Tell me, friend, is that not perfectly true? Is it not what you feel as keenly as I do?

Hasmon. Oh yes, you have spoken from my heart. But may I ask you to tell me your story?

Adin. Most gladly. It will be a refreshment for my hungry spirit. I am the son of a minister in Germany. My father was a good orthodox man who believed everything in his Bible and the books of confession, and he wanted me to believe it all too. I followed him faithfully, did whatever he asked, and believed it all without any deep conviction, just as he did. That lasted until I went to university. I was to become a minister too, and my mother was already looking forward to seeing me in the pulpit. I expected to learn a discipline, to discover irrefutable proofs of the truth of Christianity, and to have grounds at last for what I believed. How far from it!

The doctors of Scripture seemed quietly and covertly to do all they could to sow distrust of the Bible. The Old Testament, on this telling, consisted wholly of Jewish folk histories, fables and uncertain legends. Moses was a great man and lawgiver to them, but one who used many means to deceive a crude and ignorant people. God had no direct part in the affair. They did not say all this outright, but any listener with half his wits about him had to draw that conclusion. They called the prophetic books Hebrew poems. Some past events, they said, were foretold as future events in lofty language. Other things were dimly foreseen and presented in mystical, oracular terms. These things afterwards either happened by chance or could be understood as referring to certain events.

They always spoke of Christ with reverence, but once one drew out the real import of their hyperboles, criticisms and scattered assertions, he was simply a virtuous, devout and wise man who sealed his life and teaching with a martyr’s death.[2] They were prudent enough to call much in the Bible allegory and spare it the name of fable. In the end only Christian morality remained. It seemed to be the real aim and purpose of all theology, and all else was a matter of indifference. “Do only what moral teaching commands, then believe whatever you please, or believe nothing at all.” Once the Bible becomes an ordinary old history book, naturally one believes only what one experiences and what reason can comprehend. One senses that there is a God, but he is a stranger, and one knows nothing of his relation to human beings. One has an intimation of immortality, but what one will become is deeply hidden. One feels free, but on examining that freedom closely, one finds oneself bound by an iron necessity, and is still supposed to do what morality commands.[3]

That was my study of theology. You can easily imagine that I did not become a minister. I chose philosophy and the humanities, studied Helvétius and Hume, and read Shakespeare through twenty times. The Greeks and Romans were the world I lived in. I enjoyed life perhaps rather more than I should have, for my body grew infirm. As a lecturer I taught what I had learned at the university and took no further interest in religion. I lived to see the triumph of humanity, the general urge for liberty and equality, and died. Now my condition is miserable, and I do not know what will become of me. But tell me your story now.

Hasmon. In essentials it differs little from yours. All the religious ideas they taught you are mine too, and are surely true, if reason is reason at all. It is our only guide and lawgiver, and if there is a just God, he can only judge us according to the conviction of our reason.[4] I too was the son of a minister, but I studied law and became an advocate. I too enjoyed the world and ruined my body. But alas, I had to leave a dear wife and two children for ever. It pains me beyond words! What makes my grief unbearable is that here one cannot even weep. One withers in the oppressive heat.

Adin. Poor spirit! In that respect I have the better of it. I did not marry. I loved variety.

Hasmon. Even with a wife I loved variety too.

Adin. That was wrong![5]

Hasmon. Is it wrong to satisfy one’s needs? But tell me how it went with you when you died.

Adin. I had long been weak. At last I developed consumption without knowing or suspecting it. I always thought I would get better, and my friends and my doctor tried to persuade me of it, but I grew visibly sicker. I often doubted I would recover. Then people would argue that it was hypochondria, and I would quieten down again. All at once I felt as though I were fainting. I lost consciousness and dreamed I was out on a moonlit night in a lonely field ringed by a tall, dark forest. I gathered my wits and found I could float away. I drifted here and there quite lightly without moving my limbs, and it pleased me. By degrees I entered the dark forest and floated between the branches, feeling neither weight nor weariness.

At last I seemed to enter a dark, vaulted passage with open window holes down one side, through which the moon shone into the darkness. I felt the chill one feels in old ruins when afraid of ghosts. I floated along halfway up the passage and noticed that it sloped gradually downwards and wound continually around. A deep, wistful sense of loneliness and abandonment passed through me. I tried to go back, but could not, and found myself in a great, dim hall. There stood a long black table. Around it sat men in black cloaks and round hats, all with their faces laid on their arms on the table. A dreadful stillness reigned everywhere. Suddenly a muffled voice rang out from the side. “Woe! Woe! Woe! Adin is dead!” All the men started up and stared at me with hollow eyes in ashen faces. I was terrified as never before and woke. I woke forwards, forwards into this dreadful dark wilderness, instead of returning to my life on earth. Here I am now and do not know what I shall become.[6] Now tell me about your own passage from the beautiful world into this realm of the dead.

Hasmon. After so much indulgence I began at last to grow weak and sickly. My wife grieved deeply. I had to support her and the children, since we had no inherited fortune. When I could no longer earn much, we began to suffer hardship. I often regretted that I had not saved money and taken care of my health. Then I reproached myself for that regret, proving to myself that we were fast bound to an iron necessity. What had happened could not be altered. In the present we were bound by past and therefore unalterable causes, which continued to act upon us irresistibly. The future was hidden from us, so we could not avert what it had in store. In short, I was altogether innocent.[7] These arguments numbed me into a passive calm, but brought no joy.

Suddenly I was seized by a raging fever. From the time I took to my bed I was no longer conscious of myself, apart from a few dim, oppressive, painful hours.[8] At last I fell into a state of obscure impressions. I seemed to be in a dark dungeon, lit at times by a bluish flame of sulphur that appeared and disappeared. Horrible, utterly loathsome creatures crawled around me, hissing and chattering at me. My consciousness seemed to grow clearer through the fear I felt. Then the sulphurous light lasted longer. My horror increased and the creatures grew larger and more dreadful. In an instant a nameless monster appeared and sprang at me. I woke from the cruel terror, but alas, I woke in this sad land of darkness instead of returning to my former life. Tell me, friend, what do you think of our condition? What will become of us?[9]

Adin. However sad beyond words our state may now be, my reason tells me that we cannot possibly become more unhappy. Did we make ourselves as we are? Are we to blame for being better fitted and more inclined to the pleasures of the senses than to strict virtue? What could we do about the world around us being full of temptations to vice? No, it cannot go ill with us. This intermediate state we are now in need not make us anxious about the future.[10]

Hasmon. I do not know how it is, but that comfort will not take hold.[11] I suppose there is nothing to say against it, but look, friend, who is coming towards us from far away? He looks somewhat unlike us, yet he seems to be a human spirit. I do not quite trust him by his appearance. He has something about him of the friends of religion I once knew and could not abide.[12]

Adin. Let us see what he wants.

Abiel approaches them with his glory veiled.

Abiel. I have come to explain a great mystery to you.

Hasmon. What great mystery?

Abiel. How time and eternity are connected.

Hasmon and Adin are startled.

Hasmon. We know that. Our reason tells us so.

Abiel. If you know the great mystery, tell me what awaits you.

Hasmon. If justice prevails here, a higher, more perfect state must await us.

Abiel. Yes, the truest, most perfect justice prevails here. You shall judge for yourselves whether that state can be your lot according to its decision.

Hasmon. First we must know whether you have the right to call us to account.

Abiel sends rays into the innermost being of both spirits. They begin to be unveiled.

Hasmon and Adin. In alarm and astonishment. Great stranger, we see that you are a being of a higher order. Speak. We will listen.

Abiel. The Exalted One has sent me to announce his judgement to you. He wishes each person to recognise the justice of his judgement. Since you think you know the great mystery and are convinced he owes you a higher, more perfect state, you must pronounce judgement upon yourselves. I will prepare you to do so. Your own reason shall decide.

Adin. That is very gracious, and also fair.

Hasmon. Yes, that is true. We can ask no more.

Abiel. What does your reason say of someone who does good as far as his influence reaches, even to those who harm or insult him? Someone who bears with everyone with love and gentleness, bows before all in true humility, seeks no place above others and gladly gives precedence to them all. Someone who shuns every vice and lives out his days in purity of heart, enjoys every permissible pleasure in moderation, and bears every suffering patiently, letting it ennoble and improve him. Tell me, what do you think of such a spirit?

Hasmon. That he is virtuous, very noble and good.

Adin. Yes, I am convinced of it.

Abiel. If you are convinced that virtue ennobles human beings and makes them more perfect as it increases, examine yourselves and tell me where that conviction comes from.

Adin. Human nature is so constituted that it cannot help feeling the beauty, perfection and high worth of virtue, and taking pleasure in that feeling.

Abiel. Is that your opinion too, Hasmon?

Hasmon. Yes, for it is true.

Abiel. Does it not follow, then, from the very constitution of human nature that in all its capacities it is meant to become virtuous and to grow continually in holiness?

Adin. Yes, it follows naturally and there is no doubt about it. But that is just where the contradiction lies. A person is meant by all his capacities to become virtuous, but has no strength to do so. An iron fate drags him along with the current. His sensual inclinations are irresistible and grow stronger as time goes on. How can God require virtue of a person to whom he has denied the strength to acquire it?[15]

Abiel. Experience shows that he has not denied that strength to everyone, for there are many noble people. But was it denied to the two of you?

Adin. In my case the attractions of sensuality were irresistible. I was carried by force from one pleasure to another.

Hasmon. That was true of me too.

Abiel. That is to say, you had motives for virtue on one side and motives for sensual pleasure and vice on the other. In your opinion, then, the fault is that the motives for sensual pleasure and vice acted far more powerfully than the former ones?

Hasmon. Certainly. If God had put stronger incentives to virtue in human beings than to sensual pleasure, we would both have become perfectly virtuous.

Adin. Most certainly!

Abiel. Suppose two generals go to war. One faces an enemy weaker than himself, the other a stronger one. If both return victorious, which of the two is the greater hero?

Adin. Undoubtedly the latter.

Abiel. Can one call a man brave, a hero, for conquering a weaker enemy?

Hasmon. No!

Abiel. Would someone have the virtue of abstinence if he faced only slight temptations to lust that he could easily overcome?

Hasmon. No. Abstinence would come naturally to him.

Abiel. Would there be any virtue at all if the motives for it acted on a person more strongly than the attractions of vice?

Adin. No. Virtue would then be merely a natural inclination.

Abiel. Quite right! The one who overcomes the stronger attractions of sensuality and wins virtue through struggle is truly virtuous and truly deserves a reward.

Hasmon. All that is perfectly true. But what if a person has no strength at all for the struggle, and is borne away irresistibly by the attraction of sensual pleasure?

Abiel. Such a person, then, has no freedom of will, and his actions are neither virtuous nor vicious. Can that be true of rational beings, whose will is determined by what their reason judges to be good or otherwise?[13]

Adin. It would certainly appear not. But reason convinces us that all causes act of necessity. At every moment when the will is determined, its causes are already past and can no longer be changed. We are therefore determined by necessity, and since we do not know the future, we cannot provide against it.[14]

Abiel. Suppose someone decides to enjoy a pleasure and makes all the arrangements. Then an opportunity presents itself for a still greater, more agreeable pleasure. Does he abandon the first and choose the second?

Hasmon. Of course he does.

Abiel. Is his will therefore determined by the idea of a greater good or pleasure? Is the human will generally determined by what seems most agreeable to it, except when pressing needs compel a person to act otherwise?

Adin. Yes, that cannot possibly be denied.

Abiel. Well then, he acts freely, for he chooses what seems best to him. Would virtue have determined your will if it had held greater attractions for you than sensuality?

Hasmon. Yes, it would have led us to become virtuous.

Abiel. Now judge for yourselves. You recognise the high worth of virtue, and you recognise that human beings, by their very capacities, are meant to grow continually in holiness. You know that the will is determined by the idea of the greater worth of a thing, and that there can be no virtue without struggle. Yet you did not set virtue before yourselves in all its beauty, or venture even the slightest struggle for its sake.[16]

Adin. Forgive me, great stranger, for still putting before you the unavoidable necessity of our actions. The unalterable causes of the past did not determine us to be moved by the greater worth of virtue to struggle against sensuality.

Abiel. When reason contradicts itself, can it be right in both cases?

Both. Impossible!

Abiel. Do you see that this is just such a case? Reason tells you that all your actions are necessary. You infer this by analogy with the physical world without even asking whether an entirely different determining principle might hold in the world of spirits, namely the moral law acting through freedom. Yet you accept your proposition as certain and irrefutable. On the other hand, that very same reason testifies to you that the supremely wise and all-good Being created human beings for virtue and holiness, which absolutely requires that the moral law determine their actions through perfect freedom. Moreover, in each individual action a person’s own feeling convinces him beyond dispute that at that moment he acts freely. He never feels an unavoidable necessity to act. Must one of these two propositions be false?

Hasmon. That cannot be denied.

Abiel. If that is so, consider which of the two must be true. If it is yours, contradiction runs through God and his rational beings. He is supreme wisdom and at the same time supreme folly, infinite love and at the same time infinite hatred. The human being is rational, capable of being determined by choosing what is best, and at the same time irrational, because necessity determines him. If we take my proposition to be true, we find wise order everywhere. Everything agrees. The only difficulty is that your reason is proud enough to judge matters beyond its limits, for which you entirely lack the premises. Your conscience must tell you that you gladly hid behind this wretched bulwark so that from behind it you could defend the gratification of your animal appetites. You took your conscience captive under the law of sin, when you should have taken your reason captive in obedience to faith.

This truth drives both spirits into a rage. They suddenly grow to the size of giants and begin to glow from within. Abiel hurls a bolt of lightning at them, and they shrink into dwarfs.

Adin. Spare us, terrible stranger! Consider that we had not the least strength to fight sensuality.

Abiel. Did you ever begin the struggle?

Adin. I tried at times, but was always defeated.

Hasmon. I never undertook it, for I knew beforehand that I would be defeated.

Abiel. In other words, you took pleasure in sensual indulgence and were unwilling to fight in earnest. Had you been constantly watchful and fought each small attraction to sensual pleasure while it was easy to overcome, your strength would have grown, and in the end you would have overcome even the greatest temptations. Consider also that the Christian religion promises help to the person who strives in earnest, and you have no excuse.

Adin. But who could assure us of the truth of a religion that contains so much that runs counter to reason?

Abiel. Which kind of reason found contradictions? Was it physical reason, which judges spiritual things by material principles and denies freedom of will, or moral reason?

Adin. Both.

Abiel. Both? Moral reason too, the reason that draws its conclusions from the principle of freedom? Poor Adin, you did not even know it!

Adin. Physical reason alone, then.

Abiel. If you were ill and someone recommended a remedy that had completely freed many others from the same complaint, would you use it even if much of what went into it seemed ill-suited to its purpose?

Adin. Yes, and I would be bound to use it.

Abiel. Why, then, did you not follow that rule in matters of religion?

Adin. Ah, sir, I am convinced, and I feel deeply that you are right. We were fools and missed the right path! Sensual pleasures delighted us so much that we disregarded everything else and had no wish to set foot on the path of virtue.

Abiel. To Hasmon. Are you convinced of this too?

Hasmon. I am compelled to say yes.

Abiel. You are guilty, then, for you went against your calling and did not enter on the path of virtue. The apparent good you did sprang from an impure source and counts for nothing to your credit. But did no evil come of your indulgence? Unroll the scrolls of your consciences!

They tremble and quake. From each spirit there unfolds a vast and terrible panorama of its history.

Abiel. There stand your deeds before your eyes. How much wealth you squandered in excess, with which you might have relieved many poor, hungry and thirsty people, widows and orphans! Yet you gave them no relief. There young women are hurrying to ruin along the road of vice. You swept them from their innocence onto this path. Their children and grandchildren, deprived of a proper upbringing, will be godless and poor. Other women lament the misery into which you plunged them and accuse you before God. Many women who sold sex sank lower still through you and became more wretched. You wronged many people. Some now await you in hell so that they can take revenge on you. Others, in the dwellings of the blessed, have left judgement to their heavenly Father. In the face of all these abominations, do you still wish to justify yourselves? If you had no strength to do good, where did you get such abundant strength for evil?

Your own consciences pronounce sentence upon you. You never walked the path of virtue and turned all your powers to the misery of others. You did not take refuge in the Redeemer of the world, and so none of the means provided for redemption avails you. Go, then, into the realm of misery and torment and receive there what is your due according to the strictest justice.

Hasmon. Horrible, horrible! Our shapes are changing. We are becoming monsters. Each of the most hideous and terrible animals lends us a limb. Our humanity deserts us, and our very existence convinces us that there are devils!

Adin. Oh, this is the cruellest torment of all, to be the most terrible apparition oneself! Eternal Judge, you knew this misery and still created us!

Abiel. And you could easily have known of it, yet chose it freely.

Adin. We were created with infinite powers for infinite enjoyment, and now infinite struggles await us, without victory, together with infinite torments. What a contradiction!

Abiel. This contradiction too will be resolved, and in the glorious majesty of the Exalted One you shall recognise his justice.

An irresistible pull carries them towards the eternal west. Abiel withdraws.

Abiel. To himself. O infinitely glorious One, breathe strength upon me from your sanctuary! A finite creature like me gives way at the sight of such misery. You alone, who take in eternity in a single glance and live beyond time, can set before your heart, which overflows with love for all your creatures, the blessed consequences of designs that surpass all finite understanding. Even an angel still needs faith and hope. Lord, I believe and hope!

Hasmon. As he is drawn towards the realm of hell. What did the heavenly one say? That this contradiction would be resolved, and that in the glorious majesty of the Exalted One we should recognise his justice?

Adin. Yes, he said that, and deep in my spirit I feel something that agrees with it. I will fix my eyes on that point for ever. When terror takes me in my unending shipwreck on the ocean of misery, I will stare towards those misty mountains glimmering on the horizon, strive towards them and hope that they are land.

Hasmon. And for me that thought shall be a thread by which I will find my way out of the eternal labyrinths.

A voice like a trumpet sounds through the eternal night.

Humble yourselves under the mighty hand of God, that he may exalt you at the proper time.

1 Peter 5:6

Author’s note

If the conscientious Christian should think that the hope I have expressed here and there of the eventual redemption of the condemned might have harmful consequences, I ask him to remember that so very uncertain a conjecture can foster a sense of security only in those who would be lost in any case. Whoever can be held back from vice only by the prospect of torments without end is unfit for the kingdom of God.

English translation from Scenen aus dem Geisterreiche, Frankfurt am Main, Varrentrapp und Wenner, 1795, pp. 67–94. This reading text follows the first edition.

Notes and Commentary from the German Reading Text

These notes follow the German reading text. That text combines annotations attributed to Jung-Stilling with later commentary of partly uncertain authorship. The original numbering is retained.

“The subject of this scene,” Stilling explains, “is of the utmost importance in our days, for almost all religious doubt, and I might say the whole power of darkness, rests on philosophical fatalism and determinism. May this scene be read attentively and taken to heart.”

As Stilling rightly observes, those who make earthly pleasure the substance of their lives will become incapable of feeling at home in the world beyond. They will undoubtedly feel the loss of worldly pleasures as a privation. In this way they remove themselves from the company of the truly blessed. It need not be so. We must strive for moral perfection and sanctification while on earth. Only when the soul is holy, healed of all the weaknesses of the body, can it unite itself with God. The sole purpose of human life in this world is release from the darkness of life governed by the flesh and the sanctification just described.

Permissible, beneficial pleasure of the senses serves only to strengthen us. Stilling also discusses in this chapter the view, still frequently encountered today, that Jesus Christ was merely a virtuous and devout man. He answers many questions that sceptics put to us even now, almost two hundred years later, in the same terms as then. Stilling has an exemplary faith and the courage to profess it in the face of ridicule:

1) I cannot understand how anyone can be so foolish as to set his own folly up as judge over divine wisdom. But this is the way of reason. It would sooner blame God than acknowledge a master above itself.

2) Christ himself declares quite unambiguously that he is the only-begotten Son of God, who was with the Father in divine glory before the foundation of the world. Could a virtuous, devout and wise man say this if it were untrue?

In this scene Stilling also reminds us that excessive intellectual reasoning can be of little use, particularly when it comes at the expense of the soul’s development. His next words sound like a cry:

3) Great God, if only I could have written all this in letters of fire! I testify before God and all the heavenly host that every interpretation which does not rest on a biblical foundation is a plague to theology and Christianity. How can reason in all its wisdom presume to master God’s revelation?

We truly know little and often esteem passing stages of development more highly than inward maturation, which needs no outward proofs or explanations. Thus we can fall into false doctrines and come to regard intellectual inquiry as the chief and deciding thing.

This is a danger that especially threatens people today. How many other forms of religion and how many sects continually appear and try to present the teaching of Jesus Christ as good in itself, but as only one way to salvation. Here we must rely completely on the words of the Redeemer, even now:

“No one comes to the Father except through me!”

That says it all.

“What does it profit a person to gain the whole world, and all its knowledge, if he suffers loss in his soul?”

According to Stilling, it profits us nothing. Nor can some peoples derive any benefit from acts of self-torment, to take one example.

Letting “absolute reason” govern was and remains a great danger, for the highest reason we should in fact attain is unconditional faith in the Son of God. Over the centuries we have also seen how much the teachings of reason differ from one age to another and how readily they can be twisted. Stilling thought so too:

4) Even when our reason is built on reliable premises, it is a many-headed monster. By which head is God to judge? And what if reason has closed its eyes to truth and let itself be ruled by sensual desires?

5) Now we already have two kinds of reason. Which of them is God to judge by? On that principle the authorities would have to let every criminal pass sentence on himself.

Reading the passage in which Adin describes his death, we can readily see why the passage of an unbeliever into the realm of light would be difficult. Stilling then relates how enlightening his dreams had been with regard to the questions raised:

6) In this work I have never filled the interval between the extinction of self-awareness in this life and the quiet awakening in the spirit world with a dream. I have a strong intuition that this is how it is, although I can give no reason for it. Psychology has nothing to say against it.

Indeed, in religious questions our reason often becomes a snare that leads to ruin, or a chain, as Stilling calls it:

7) This is the iron chain of reason to which the soul is fettered to its eternal ruin if it does not hold to the Gospel with simplicity. Farther on it will be broken.

But what happens if one day illness paralyses this celebrated rational thinking?

Here again Stilling gives the right answer:

8) This happens so often to the sick. How necessary it is, then, to put our affairs with God in order while we are in good health.

Some passages may seem strange to what is all too human in us. They may even make us doubt what we read. Stilling knows this too and comments on it:

9) Dear reader, I tell no fairy tales and no poetic invention. Certain truth lies at the heart of the form I have given it. Take care, oh, take care, that you pass into the world beyond with faith, love and hope.

These assurances bring peace. In its own way the seemingly divided account convinces us by leading in the end to the one goal we ought to seek and wish to attain if we call ourselves followers of Christ, even where the account takes many forms and seems contradictory.

10) What a contradiction! They are inexpressibly sad and yet have no cause to be sad. Everything they did, they were obliged to do, and yet they have an intimation of punishment. Why else would they be sad?

The reference to the voice of conscience is especially important. We can see why Stilling says in his explanation of this chapter:

11) That is exactly the point. Conscience is at odds with reason. What, then, will become of the soul that fails to master corrosive intellectual reasoning?

Will it fare as Hasmon did?

12) Here the seal of Satan and the mark of the beast make themselves known. Hasmon cannot bear the features of Christ. Examine how you feel, dear reader, when you see a true and deeply mature Christian. Your feeling will then pronounce judgement on you.

Our feelings? How often they depend on mere outward appearances. How much we have become slaves to our senses and physical desires, often without noticing it. Yet redemption already lies within what appears to be the seed of destruction.

13) It cannot be said often enough that there is no clearer and more irrefutable proof of the complete freedom of the will than the fact that human beings possess reason. Without freedom their reason would be entirely pointless.

What makes the situation of the people described here so serious is that they repeatedly appeal to their ignorance of eternal law, taking cover behind their “weakness” and showing no will to surrender in faith. Stilling reminds them that:

14) God does nothing without a purpose. Whatever is uncorrupted in human nature is therefore destined to attain the purpose for which it was created.

We possess a will of our own and must use it. Those who neglect to do so should not be surprised if they must bear the consequences.

15) Notice the leap in the reasoning. He assumes that God withheld these powers from human beings and overlooks all the great arrangements God made for them to acquire those powers.

Here Stilling appeals urgently to those who are more hesitant and discouraged:

16) Oh, all you readers, if only I could write these words in your hearts in letters of fire! Unwillingness to imagine virtue and unwillingness to dare are the chief obstacles that keep people from taking refuge in Christ.

Notes 15 and 16 were checked against Jung-Stilling, Scenen aus dem Geisterreiche, 1843, pp. 79 and 82. The final words of note 16 are supplied from that edition.

Back to the contents

Previous: The Poor Man

Next: The Surprise

← Back to overview