← Back to overview

On Justification

← Back to The Most Misinterpreted Concepts in the Bible

Paul wrote to the Romans (4:5): Whoever does no works but believes in Him who justifies the ungodly has their faith counted as righteousness, according to the decree of God’s grace. I, as Jehovah, already answered this false teaching through the prophet Ezekiel as follows:

2. Ezekiel 33:14–19: When I, Jehovah, tell the ungodly man that he shall die, and he turns from his sin and does what is right and good, returning a pledge unjustly held, making restitution for what he has stolen, and walking according to the word of life so that he does no evil, he shall live and shall not die. None of the sins he committed shall be remembered, for he now does what is right and good. Therefore he shall live. If the righteous man abandons his righteousness and does evil, it is only just that he should die for it. If the ungodly man turns from his sinful life and does what is right and good, it is only just that he should live for it.

These words of the prophet Ezekiel teach you that I do not make the ungodly righteous by grace. Only when the ungodly man turns back and does what is truly good do I forgive his sins and graciously receive him into life.

If someone continually wrongs you, he incurs your displeasure, anger, and complaint. But if he recognizes his wrong, asks your forgiveness, and makes amends for what he has done, you forgive his sins as well. Is it not the same with Me and the ungodly? Certainly it is. Just as you forgive an enemy only after he has done everything to make things right with you, so do I, and I cannot do otherwise. I cannot have ungodly people in heaven, because heaven would then turn into hell. From this you see that Paul spoke from himself rather than from Me and therefore uttered and set forth a falsehood. Several further teachings will make this clear to you.

Matthew 12:35, 37: The good person brings forth good from a good store, and the evil person brings forth evil from an evil store. Verse 36: But I, Jesus, tell you that people will have to give account on the day of judgement for every idle word they speak. Verse 37: By your good words (and deeds) you will be justified, and by your (evil) words (and deeds) you will be condemned.

My own words in Matthew tell you that evil and ungodly people are judged according to their evil words and deeds and do not become righteous by grace. Who, then, spoke the truth, I, Christ, or Paul? If you defend Paul, I, Christ, appear to be a liar. If you believe Me, you must acknowledge that Paul set forth a false teaching, reject it, and believe Me.

Matthew 7:1–2: In the Sermon on the Mount I said, “Do not judge, so that you may not be judged. The same measure you give will be measured back to you.”

The following sayings from Holy Scripture shed light on this saying:

Galatians 6:7–8: Paul says, “Dear brothers, make no mistake. God is not mocked. Whatever a person sows, that is what they will reap. Whoever sows to the flesh will reap corruption from the flesh. Whoever sows to the spirit will reap eternal life from the spirit.”

The last words, “eternal life,” make everything clear. The meaning is: Do not judge the words and deeds of your brothers or your neighbours unjustly here, lest in the next life you be judged for your injustice by eternal life, that is, by Christ (John 14:6). With the same measure you give out good or evil here on earth, it will be measured back to you in the next life as your recompense.

So too the other saying means that what a person sows on earth, they will reap in the next life. There is therefore no justification by grace, and these words directly deny that I make the ungodly righteous by grace.

No sensible person will regard the Revelation of John as a human work. Yet there too it says that people’s good works follow them into the next life as a reward (Revelation 14:13). It also says that the works of the wicked follow them into the next life and that they are judged by their evil works (Revelation 20:12). You are therefore told that judgement and justice await you in the next life. Nowhere are you told that I make anyone righteous by grace, least of all the ungodly!

First Corinthians 15:42 also says that what is sown is perishable and what rises is imperishable. One sows, namely the person in the flesh, and another reaps, namely the spirit of the departed person in the next life (John 4:36–37). If evil has been sown, good cannot be reaped, any more than weeds can ripen into wheat. Whoever sows the wind reaps the storm (Hosea 8:7).

Matthew 5:26: I said in the Sermon on the Mount, “Truly, no one will come out of prison until they have paid the last penny.”

This verse means that no one is justified until they renounce their sins, root them out of themselves, and firmly resolve to live devoutly or righteously. Sin is the prison and death of the soul. Thus each verse tells you that no one is saved by grace, but only through their own effort and toil, for which I grant them My divine help.

What kind of divine justice would it be if the devout person who struggles for many years to live by My laws were put on the same footing as the ungodly person who has done nothing but evil at the expense of others, abusing, exploiting, cheating, or robbing them, and who would then be regarded as righteous and declared saved outright by grace?

Paul writes to Timothy: “Watch yourself and your teaching. Persevere in these things. If you do so, you will save both yourself and those who hear you” (1 Timothy 4:16). This is the right and only true teaching. The diligent worker is paid, while the idler is sent away. Should I, the all-wise God, act less wisely than people do?

From these brief explanations it is clear that the Protestant doctrine of justification according to Paul and Luther is entirely false and extremely dangerous to a person’s salvation. An unrepentant life leads in place of the heaven one hopes for to hell, the worm of conscience that does not die, the chattering of teeth, and the flames of hell. Anyone who wants a fuller explanation of justification before God should read the Christian Theosophical book on Luther.

John the Evangelist writes in 1:5–8: This is the message of Jesus that we heard from Him and proclaim to you:

God is light (that is, crystal pure in the sense of the teaching on divine love and wisdom in the Gospel). There is therefore no darkness in Him (no sin, vice, or unholy quality). If we say we have fellowship with Him but walk in darkness (in sin and false belief), we lie and do not speak the truth.

But if we walk in the light (free from sin and vice, without giving in to the desires of the flesh, without evil inclinations or passions, without selfishness or self-love, in the highest love for God and in utterly unselfish love for our neighbour, as God loves humanity or as a mother loves her child; full of humility, as Jesus was on the way of suffering; full of patience, compassion, and mercy toward friend and foe, like God, who sends sunshine and life-giving rain with equal love upon sinners and the righteous; full of love for peace, earnest chastity, purity, willingness to be reconciled, forgiveness, and selflessness), as God is in the spiritual light described here, then we have fellowship with one another (as in early Christianity, when what was mine was yours and what was yours was mine). And then the blood of Jesus Christ (Christ’s selfless and therefore purely spiritual divine love for us, His children) cleanses us from all sin.

If we say that we have no sins (and that Christ’s blood shed on the cross once and for all wiped out even the sins we commit now under the second testament), we deceive and mislead ourselves and the truth is not in us. What is in us is a falsehood we have chosen, for the prophets and apostles taught otherwise, as the preceding evidence shows.

John goes on to write in 2:1: My children, I write this to you so that you may not sin. And if anyone does sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous.

We saw above that no one is saved by grace for their New Testament sins. This grace applies only to the sins of the Old Testament, up to the death on the cross.

When Peter asked how often one ought to forgive one’s neighbour as a brother, I, Jesus, replied that it should be done seventy-seven times. But with the divine King this can happen only when you kneel and ask forgiveness in heartfelt contrition, firmly resolved to make good every wrong, and when you do the same toward your enemies. Such is the teaching in Matthew 18:21–35, which everyone should consider carefully. As you act toward your neighbours, so will I, Jesus, act. Thus I am a righteous advocate with My Father if you too are righteous and do to your neighbour what you wish Me to do to you.

The next verse in John, 2:2, reads: Jesus is the atonement for our sins and for the sins of the whole world.

The following evidence shows that this verse has quite a different meaning from the preceding one and therefore does not refer to it (paragraph 23). God’s reconciliation with Himself (1 Corinthians 5:18–19) through redemption on the cross from the sins of the Old Testament was established above from Genesis 2:17 and chapter 3, Hebrews 9:15, and Romans 3:25 (see chapters 1–3 above, ChtS 71, chapter XIX).

That this reasoning is true can be seen from John 2:22–23, where he says, “Whoever denies Jesus Christ as the Son of God does not have the Father either.” Now four fifths of the people in the world either have never heard of Me or do not believe that I, Jesus, am a Son of God. And yet John says that I, Jesus, am the atonement for the whole world! The statement is true if it refers to sin under the Old Testament. If it is joined to paragraph 23 and read as having one meaning with it, only nonsense and falsehood result.

The fact is that original sin no longer exists, and therefore neither does the forecourt of hell where the devout of the Old Testament waited for the Redeemer. For I, the Redeemer of Golgotha so long and eagerly awaited, came and led them into My holy Father’s house, thereby founding the New Jerusalem (John 19:17; Hebrews 10:10, 14).

But you, dear children, need not wait in the forecourt of hell in the next life. Through My suffering and death on the cross I saved you from that by grace, suffering and dying Myself to bear the penalty imposed on you because of original sin.

Yet the sins you bring upon yourselves in this life you must atone for yourselves. Otherwise you will go to hell instead of heaven. That is why I taught people to pray the Lord’s Prayer, so they may remember daily that they are sinners and that sin is the spiritual death of the soul and the material death of the body. And since I, God Himself, came to fulfil the Ten Commandments, rather than abolish them, it should be clear to you that you must do the same. For, as shown above, sins committed on earth accompany you into the next life if you have not already atoned for them, and there they form your hell. Everyone builds their heaven or hell for the next life by how they live and act in this world.

Translator’s note: The biblical references follow the German source. The passages identified there as John 1:5–8, 2:1–2 and 2:22–23 occur in the First Letter of John. The passage on reconciliation cited as 1 Corinthians 5:18–19 occurs in 2 Corinthians 5:18–19.

Read in German

← Back to overview